Metal Roofing vs Clay Tiles: Pros and Cons

The roof over your head does far more than shelter you from the rain. It plays one of the biggest roles in your home’s durability, energy efficiency, and the overall aesthetic appeal. Nobody wants a house without a roof, and nobody wants a house that is leaking energy. 

With so many roofing materials available, choosing the right one is not as easy as you think. Two of the most popular comparisons to make are metal roofing vs clay tiles. While both could be excellent choices for your home, each of these materials comes with its own set of characteristics, pros, and cons. When you understand the differences, you’ll be able to make a more informed decision about which roofing material to choose.

In this article, we’re going to dive in and explore those features, advantages, and drawbacks of metal roofing vs clay tiles to help you to decide which roofing material will suit your needs, climate, and budget. 

Metal Roofing

Metal roofing is a contemporary option, and it has gained immense popularity over the years. With its unparalleled durability and sleek design, its energy efficient properties simply give it a boost. It’s a compelling choice for homeowners who are looking for that long term value. So here’s what you need to know about it:

Pros of Metal Roofing

1. Metal roofing offers durability. Over the years, metal roofs have long been celebrated for their exceptional durability because when they are properly installed and maintained, they can last you for up to 50 years. Premium metal materials such as zinc or copper can even exceed 100 years in its life span. Unlike other roofing materials, metal doesn’t crack, warp or shrink overtime, and that makes it highly resistant to aging.
2. Metal roofing is resilient. Metal roofing is engineered to endure severe weather conditions. This includes heavy rain, high winds, and even wildfire. This level of resilience makes it a great choice for homes in regions that are prone to unpredictable or harsh weather conditions. Unlike organic materials, metal roofs are not vulnerable to mold, rot, or pest infestations.
3. It’s energy efficient. If you’re looking for a material that saves you money, one of the standout features of metal roofing is that its energy efficiency levels are through the roof, no pun intended. Metal roofs will reflect solar heat instead of absorbing it, and that helps to maintain a cooler indoor temperature during the summer. When you combine it with a reflective coating or cool roof technology, this feature can lead to huge savings on air conditioning costs. In colder climates, metal roofing also sheds snow quickly, which reduces the risk of ice dams building up.
4. It’s a sustainable option. Metal roofing can align with your sustainability goals as most metal roofs are made from recyclable materials at the end of their lifespan. They are also 100% recyclable themselves and won’t go to landfill.
5. Metal roofing is low maintenance. If you’re looking for a low maintenance option that you can feel confident will remain in the best condition, you’ll appreciate metal roofing. Unlike wood options or asphalt, metal doesn’t require frequent painting, ceiling, or repairs. With routine inspections and occasional cleaning, you’ll be able to keep your metal roof in top condition.
6. It’s a versatile option for design. Modern metal roofing comes in a range of colors, styles and finishes, which allows you to customize your roof’s appearance. Some metal roofs even mimic the look of traditional shingles, clay tiles or slate. 

Cons of Metal Roofing

1. There is a higher cost upfront. Metal roofing can provide long term savings, but its upfront cost is often more than other roofing materials. You should weigh this initial investment against the durability, energy savings, and reduce maintenance costs over time to see whether it’s worth it.
2. It’s not a soundproof option. Metal roofs can be noisy during heavy rain or hail storms, which can be a concern for some homeowners. However, you are able to add soundproofing, insulation or a noise reducing underlayment during installation so that you can reduce this issue significantly.
3. Metal can dent. Certain metals, such as aluminum, are more susceptible to dents from hail or falling branches. You can choose a thicker metal or a more durable option, however, such as copper or zinc, which can mitigate this risk.
4. Thermal expansion. With temperature changes, metal roofing can expand and contract and that can cause stress on the fasteners overtime. As long as you are having it installed properly by experienced professionals, you’ll be able to minimize this issue as much as possible. 

Clay Tiles

One of the oldest roofing materials is clay, having been used for centuries in Mediterranean, Spanish and Southwestern architecture. Clay tiles are renowned for their aesthetic appeal and natural durability, and they remain a popular choice for homeowners who would like a sophisticated and long lasting roof.

Pros of Clay Tiles

1. Incredible longevity. Clay tiles are a one time investment for many homeowners. They come with an exception, more lifespan, and with proper care they can last 50 to 100 years or more. Their durability ensures that they remain an attractive option even in harsh climates.
2. Natural threat resistance. From fire and insects to rot, clay tiles are resistant to a range of natural threats, and their ability to withstand extreme conditions such as heavy winds and intense sunlight make them a reliable roofing choice.
3. Energy efficiency. Clay tiles have thermal properties which make them highly energy efficient. They provide natural insulation, helping to regulate indoor temperatures by keeping homes cool in hot climates and warmer in cold ones. They also reflect the heat away from the home, which enhances their energy efficiency.
4. Clay tiles are low maintenance. Similarly to metal roofs, clay tiles require minimal maintenance. They do not need regular painting, sealing, or chemical treatment.
5. They are timeless. Clay tiles have long been synonymous with elegance and timeless charm, their distinctive look at character – just look at any old European home.
6. Environmentally friendly. If you’re looking for a natural material for your roof, clay tiles are a great choice. They’re an environmentally sustainable option, and while they are not as recyclable as metal roofs, their long life span reduces the need for frequent replacement. 

Cons of Clay Tiles

1. High initial cost. Clay tiles are some of the most expensive roofing materials around. The cost is not only driven by the price of the tiles themselves, but also by the fact that the installation process is labor intensive.
2. They’re heavy. One of the biggest drawbacks of clay tiles is the weight. They are significantly heavier than metal roofing and other materials, and they often require additional structural support. This added weight can increase the cost and the complexity of the installation itself. 
3. They are fragile. Despite their longevity, clay tiles are prone to cracking or breaking, especially under heavy impact. If there’s a falling tree branch or improper foot traffic, you can find cracks across your play tiles. Homeowners should be careful not to walk on clay tile roofs, and professionals should always be hired for maintenance and repairs.
4. Is complex. Installing clay tiles requires expertise and proper alignment. Poor installation can lead to leaks, structural support issues, and issues with water resistance.

Which Roofing Material is Right for You?

There are several factors to consider when choosing metal roofing VS clay tiles.

• Climate plays a huge role in determining the best roofing material for your home. Metal is great for areas prone to heavy rain, snow or wind, but cochlear tiles perform exceptionally well in hot, sunny climates.
• The cost up front. Both metal roofing and clay tiles involve a high initial investment, however the longevity and energy efficiency of both materials provides long term savings upfront. If the cost that you pay out initially is a concern, metal roofing can offer a slightly more cost effective solution due to its lightweight nature.
• Aesthetics, The style of your home and the personal design preferences you have will influence your decision. Metal roofs offer a wide variety of traditional and modern styles, while clay tiles are best suited for homes of the classic look.
• Structural integrity. Before determining clay tiles are the best for you, it’s essential to assess whether your home structure can support the weight. Metal roofing, as its lightweight does not pose this issue.
• Your sustainability goals. Are you an environmentally conscious homeowner? Both metal roofing and clay tiles are sustainable options, but metal roofing’s recyclability makes it a standout choice.

Both metal roofing and clay tiles are great roofing options with unique benefits. Ultimately, the choice between metal roofing and clay tiles will come down to your needs, your budget, and your personal preference. By evaluating the pros and cons we provided for you, you can make an informed decision that enhances the value, the comfort, and the curb appeal of your home. Take a look through our comparison above and make your choice.