One of the ways that you can upgrade the exterior of your home is with siding. In fact, it’s one of the most impactful ways to make a difference to your home’s exterior because not only does it enhance the curb appeal, but it provides an additional layer of protection from the weather.
When it comes to choosing siding, however, there are two popular materials that dominate the conversation, metal siding and fiber cement siding. There are unique advantages and disadvantages to both, and choosing the right one for your home is going to depend on a whole range of fractures that we’re going to go through in this article.
Let’s take a look at the difference between metal versus fiber cement siding. When we compare key features such as moisture control, weight, sustainability, fire resistance, and more, you’ll have a better understanding of which option could be the best fit for your home. Both materials offer their own benefits, but ultimately, metal siding comes out on top, and here’s why.
Moisture Control
When you’re choosing siding, moisture control should be one of the first priorities. You need it to resist moisture because moisture can wreak havoc on the exterior and the interior of your home, leading to mold growth, warping and structural damage overtime.
Metal Siding
Metal siding is impervious to water. There is no absorption issue with metal siding at all, as it doesn’t swell or allow mold to grow either. The quality of this makes metal sliding especially ideal for homes that are in humid or rainy climates where moisture intrusion is a common concern. Since metal is non porous, metal siding helps to maintain the structural integrity of your home over the long term.
Fiber Cement Siding
On the other hand, fiber cement siding is not waterproof. It contains a very high moisture content during manufacturing and that can make it susceptible to absorbing water throughout its lifespan. You’ll find that this leads to swelling, shrinking, or warping of those panels overtime, especially if they’re not installed correctly. Any gaps between panels or improper ceiling will allow water to penetrate, and this compromises the facade and leads to premature failure. If you live in a wet climate, this is a very big downside to consider.
Winner: Metal siding is the clear winner here. Its moisture resistance and ability to prevent mold growth make it the superior choice.
Maintenance
Another important consideration when you’re comparing siding options is the level of maintenance that is required to keep them looking at the way that they should look.
Metal Siding
Metal siding is quite low maintenance when you install it. It requires little to no upkeep over the time that it’s installed. Unlike other materials, metal siding doesn’t require repainting or sealing over its lifespan. The surface is durable, so it resists any fading, chipping, and peeling, which means that you can continue to enjoy a polished look for a long time without any significant effort on your part.
Fiber Cement Siding
Fiber cement siding demands a lot more maintenance compared to metal. Regular repainting is a necessity so that you can protect the underlying material from any additional damage. Alongside this, you have to consistently inspect the cracks and reapply caulking as needed to prevent water infiltration and avoid mold growth. Fiber cement siding can still provide a beautiful appearance, but the ongoing maintenance requirement can be a big drawback for those who want something hassle free and easygoing.
Winner: Again, the clear winner is metal siding. With its low maintenance nature, you’ll have a convenient and cost effective choice for your siding in the long run.
Weight
Another consideration to make when you’re comparing different siding materials is the weight. This doesn’t just impact installation, but it affects the overall load that is placed on the home structure.
Metal Siding
Metal siding is lightweight. You’ll find that it weighs approximately one pound per square foot, and this characteristic makes it very easy to handle and to install. You’ll be able to reduce labour costs and simplify the installation process. The lighter weight also places less stress on your home’s framing and foundation which makes it more attractive.
Fiber Cement Siding
Fiber cement siding is significantly heavier than metal. It weighs around three pounds per square foot, and this added weight can complicate the installation process and may require additional structural support. Because the material is heavier, you may also encounter higher shipping costs and greater physical demand on the installer.
Winner: Again, metal siding is the clear winner. With its lightweight properties, you’ll find an easier and more cost effective material to work with.
Sustainability
You may be becoming increasingly eco conscious, much like most other homeowners out there. The environmental impact of building materials has become a big consideration for those who are choosing which material to use for their siding.
Metal Siding
Metal siding is environmentally friendly because it’s 100% recyclable. Once your siding has reached the end of its lifespan, it will be repurposed into new products and it won’t end up in a landfill.
Fiber Cement Siding
Fibre cement siding is unfortunately not recyclable. Due to its composite makeup, which includes sand, cement and cellulose fiber, it’s not able to be repurposed at the end of its use. This makes it the less sustainable choice.
Winner: Metal siding. As metal siding is recyclable and uses sustainable materials, you’ll find it a greener option for those who are feeling environmentally conscious about how they build their home.
Appearance
Both fiber cement siding and metal siding offer attractive aesthetics for a new house. The appearance of each material does vary depending on personal preference and the manufacturer.
Metal Siding
Modern metal siding can feature a wood grain effect finish. This mimics the natural look of wood while providing the durability and sustainability of metal. The quality of the finish will depend on the manufacturer, but technological advancements have made it possible to achieve highly realistic textures and colors. It’s a sleek, contemporary look that can complement both modern and traditional architectural styles.
Fiber Cement Siding
This is designed to resemble real wood and many homeowners find its natural appearance to be most appealing. It can be painted in a wide range of colors to match the aesthetic of your home, but its ability to maintain its appearance over time does depend on proper maintenance.
Winner: Tie. In this case, both materials are equally as good. You can achieve attractive aesthetics, but personal preference will play the biggest part.
Fire Resistance
When it comes to choosing materials for your house, fire safety is critical, particularly for homes and areas that are prone to wildfire.
Metal Siding
Metal siding is completely fireproof, but it’s also non combustible. It’s very extreme heat resistant and we will not ignite, providing excellent protection in the event of a fire.
Fiber Cement Siding
Fiber cement siding is also fire resistant due to its composition, which is primarily made of sand. It doesn’t ignite as quickly, but it’s not entirely fireproof in the same way that metal is because it contains other materials such as cellulose fiber.
Winner: Metal siding. With a material that’s 100% non combustible, it’s a safer choice for fire protection.
Installation
Installing your siding is a critical factor to consider when you’re comparing which material to use. The ease and safety of installation should be thought about earlier in the process.
Metal Siding
Metal siding is straightforward and efficient to install because the panels overlap. This allows them to expand and contract with temperature changes. Unlike other materials, metal siding doesn’t require excessive caulking and nail heads are concealed for a polished look.
Fiber Cement Siding
Fiber cement siding does present more of a challenge when it comes to installation. Cutting the material produces silica dust, and that’s hazardous to breathe and requires installers to wear respirators.
Winner: Metal siding. Metal siding is easier and safer to install, which gives it a significant edge.
Longevity
Whichever material you choose for the siding of your home, you want it to last a long time.Durability is a key consideration which determines how well it will hold up over harsh weather conditions and the years.
Metal Siding
Metal siding is both highly durable and can withstand a range of environmental factors, which include high UV rays, high winds and hail. It won’t crack, chip or peel, and it will maintain its appearance and structural integrities for decades.
Fiber Cement Siding
Fibre cement siding is also a durable option, but it doesn’t last as long as metal siding. It can crack or chip over time, and warranties for fiber cement siding are generally shorter.
Winner: Metal siding. Metal siding has superior durability and a much longer lifespan.
Façade Protection
Protecting your home’s facade from damages essential to maintaining its structural integrity and visual appeal.
Metal Siding
If you’re looking for exceptional protection against environmental factors, it’s metal that you want to choose. Even with prolonged sun exposure and hail, you’ll find that your metal siding lasts for up to 50 years while withstanding its colour and finish.
Fiber Cement Siding
Fibre cement siding does offer a level of protection, but it doesn’t match the longevity or resilience of metal siding.
Winner: Metal siding. Metal siding is able to protect your home’s facade for decades.
It’s clear that both materials have their own strengths and weaknesses, but metal siding consistently outperforms fiber cement siding in critical areas.Ultimately, metal siding is the better choice for homeowners that want something durable, low maintenance and eco friendly.